Skip to content

Medicare Advantage said no to rehab: how to appeal

A plan that denies or cuts short a skilled nursing or rehab stay must follow Medicare's coverage rules. Who can ask for a fast decision, and the time limits.

10 min readPublished November 11, 2026

Written by the CarePair team. Checked against 8 official sources. Facts checked November 11, 2026.

Reviewed by the CarePair team on November 12, 2026.

Email this guide to someone

We send them the title and a link to this page. They do not need an account.

So they know who sent it. Optional.

Optional. Please leave out health details; the email is not private.

The short answer

A Medicare Advantage plan must follow Original Medicare's coverage rules for skilled nursing care. You or a doctor can ask for a fast appeal. When a doctor says waiting could seriously jeopardize the patient's health, the plan must decide within 72 hours. If it says no again, an independent reviewer gets the case automatically. In June 2024, 19 large plan companies overturned 95 percent of the skilled nursing denials appealed.

What the plan has to follow

A Medicare Advantage plan must cover the services that Original Medicare's Part A and Part B cover. Hospice is an exception, and Original Medicare pays for it. A plan must also follow Original Medicare's general coverage rules. The federal rule names the rules for skilled nursing facility care and home health as examples. A skilled nursing facility is Medicare's name for a nursing home that gives rehab or skilled nursing.

When a plan decides whether care is medically necessary, it has to use those Medicare rules. It also has to consider the person's medical history, the doctor's recommendations, and the clinical notes. A plan may write its own coverage criteria only where Medicare's are not fully established, and those criteria must be public.

Before a plan issues a denial based on medical necessity, a doctor or other appropriate health professional must review it. Once a plan approves care through prior authorization, it may not later deny that care for lack of medical necessity, except for good cause or evidence of fraud.

Plans can differ from Original Medicare in some ways. They can require approval ahead of time, and they use networks. A plan may also cover a skilled nursing stay without the three-day hospital stay that Original Medicare requires.

Two kinds of no

A plan can say no at two points, and the appeal is different for each.

  • Before the stay. The hospital or doctor asks the plan to approve a skilled nursing or rehab admission, and the plan denies it. This appeal goes to the plan first.
  • During the stay. The plan approved the stay and now says coverage will end on a certain date. This appeal goes to an outside reviewer and has a very short deadline.
If you remember one thing

In June 2024, 19 large Medicare Advantage companies overturned 95 percent of the skilled nursing denials that were appealed to them.

Before the stay: the fast decision and the fast appeal

The plan's first answer is called an organization determination. When it is a denial, the plan must give a written notice that states the specific reasons and explains how to appeal. Medicare calls it the Notice of Denial of Medical Coverage.

The appeal to the plan is called a reconsideration. Your parent, their representative, or their doctor can ask for it. The rule gives 60 days from the day the denial notice is received. It presumes the notice arrived 5 days after its date, so Medicare's page says 65 days from the date on the notice. A request filed within 60 days of that date meets both.

A standard reconsideration can take up to 30 days. For a person waiting in a hospital bed, the fast version is the one to know. Your parent or any doctor can ask the plan to expedite, by phone or in writing. The plan must expedite when a doctor says that waiting could seriously jeopardize the person's life, health, or ability to regain maximum function. When your parent asks without a doctor, the plan decides whether the case meets that test. A fast decision is due within 72 hours, unless a limited extension applies.

The same fast track exists for the plan's first decision, so a doctor can ask for it before any denial. If the plan refuses to expedite, it must tell you promptly and follow up in writing within 3 calendar days. A plan may not punish a doctor for supporting the request.

The person who decides the reconsideration cannot be someone who took part in the first denial. When the denial is about medical necessity, the decision must be made by a doctor with expertise that fits the care.

The appeal levels and time limits

If the plan upholds its denial at level 1, it must send the case to level 2 on its own. You do not have to file anything. A plan that misses its deadline is treated as having upheld the denial, and the case moves on.

Medicare Advantage: who decides at each level, and how fast
  • Level: First decision, standard

    Who decides
    The plan
    Time limit
    7 calendar days when prior authorization is required, 14 otherwise
  • Level: First decision, fast

    Who decides
    The plan
    Time limit
    72 hours
  • Level: Level 1 reconsideration, standard

    Who decides
    The plan
    Time limit
    30 days for care not yet received
  • Level: Level 1 reconsideration, fast

    Who decides
    The plan
    Time limit
    72 hours
  • Level: Level 2

    Who decides
    An independent review entity under contract with Medicare
    Time limit
    30 days standard, 72 hours fast
  • Level: Level 3

    Who decides
    Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals
    Time limit
    Ask within 60 days. At least $200 must be at issue in 2026.
  • Level: Level 4

    Who decides
    Medicare Appeals Council
    Time limit
    Ask within 60 days
  • Level: Level 5

    Who decides
    Federal district court
    Time limit
    Ask within 60 days. At least $1,960 must be at issue in 2026.

From 42 CFR 422.568 to 422.590 and Medicare's page on health plan appeals, checked November 11, 2026. The 7-day limit began January 1, 2026. A plan or reviewer deadline can be extended by up to 14 days in limited cases, with written notice.

During the stay: the notice and the fast appeal

A plan can end coverage of a skilled nursing stay, home health care, or care in a comprehensive outpatient rehabilitation facility that it approved. The provider must then deliver a written Notice of Medicare Non-Coverage. It is due no later than two days before the care is set to end.

The fast appeal goes to an outside reviewer, the Beneficiary and Family Centered Care Quality Improvement Organization, or BFCC-QIO. It helps to call the day the notice arrives. The federal rule sets the deadline at noon of the day after the notice is delivered. The notice form and Medicare's page give it as noon of the day before the coverage end date. The notice in your hand governs, so use the deadline and the phone number printed on it.

The plan must send a detailed explanation by the close of business the day the reviewer notifies it. The plan has to show that ending coverage is correct. The reviewer must decide by the close of business of the day after it has the information it needs. Coverage continues until the date on the notice, and longer if the reviewer reverses the plan.

A late request is still accepted, but the set time limit and the payment protection do not apply. Medicare's page says a plan member who misses the deadline can also ask the plan for a fast reconsideration.

What a federal watchdog found

The Office of Inspector General at the Department of Health and Human Services reviewed these denials in a report issued in June 2026. It looked at requests for approval of a skilled nursing facility admission. The requests were handled in June 2024 by the 19 largest Medicare Advantage parent companies.

Together they denied 12 percent of the requests. Denial rates ranged from 0.4 percent to 23 percent. Enrollees and their providers appealed 18 percent of the denials. In June 2024, 19 large Medicare Advantage companies overturned 95 percent of the skilled nursing denials that were appealed to them.

The rate was not the same everywhere. Among the smaller companies, which each had fewer than 50 appeals, it was about 60 percent. The Inspector General wrote that the high overall rate indicates some enrollees were first denied care that was medically necessary. It also wrote that the data alone cannot show how many denials were wrong. The report describes those companies in that month. It does not predict the result of any one appeal.

Words to use

Have the member card and the denial notice in front of you. It helps to write down the date and time of each call and the name of the person you spoke with.

0 of 6 ticked

Saved on this device

What it can cost

A plan may charge copayments for a covered skilled nursing stay, including during the first 20 days. The amounts are set by the plan, so ask the plan what applies.

If care continues after a coverage end date and the appeal fails, your parent can be billed for that care. If a later appeal reverses the decision, the plan must pay back what your parent paid for covered care.

Before your parent is admitted anywhere without the plan's approval, you can ask the plan and the facility in writing what your parent would owe.

Who to call

  • The plan, at the member number on the card. Ask for the appeals department.
  • The hospital case manager or the facility's social worker, who can tell you what was sent to the plan.
  • The BFCC-QIO, for an appeal of coverage ending during a stay. The number is printed on the Notice of Medicare Non-Coverage.
  • Medicare: 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227), 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, except some federal holidays. TTY users can call 1-877-486-2048.
  • Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program, or SHIP, for free Medicare counseling, including help with appeals. Find it at shiphelp.org.

Why we can say this

We checked this guide against the official pages below. We link only to government agencies and established nonprofits. Each one opens on another website.

Was this helpful?

Pass it on

Email this guide to someone

We send them the title and a link to this page. They do not need an account.

So they know who sent it. Optional.

Optional. Please leave out health details; the email is not private.

General information for families. Nothing here is medical, legal, financial, or tax advice; a physician, an elder law attorney, or a licensed assessor decides the things that need deciding. Rules, amounts, and deadlines change and can differ by state, so confirm anything here before you act on it. Tell us if something here is wrong or out of date: hello@trycarepair.com.

More in Leaving the hospital or rehab

Every guide